Correction, 17 October 2026. Earlier versions of this article described a test of 24 (elsewhere 144) applications submitted through Workday, Greenhouse, Lever, Taleo, iCIMS and SAP SuccessFactors, and gave per-platform results, score changes, a recruiter survey figure, a truncation limit and a market-share number. We have no records of that test, and those figures had no source, so we have removed them. We have never submitted files through any vendor's ATS. This version explains what is generally true of how cover letters are handled, what is not published, and how to write a letter that survives text extraction.
"Should I bother with a cover letter?" is one of the most common questions applicants ask, and the answers online are split. One camp says cover letters are dead. The other says they are table stakes. The honest answer starts with what actually happens to the file after you upload it, and with being clear about what nobody outside the ATS vendors can see.
The short answer
- Most application forms accept a cover letter, either as an upload or a text box, and the employer's ATS stores it with your application.
- A text-based letter can usually be opened and searched by the recruiter. An image-only letter has no text for any software to read.
- Whether the letter's words feed any ranking or match score is not published by the major vendors, and it can depend on how each employer has set up its system. We have not tested it inside any vendor's ATS, so we won't guess.
- The reader you can count on is a person. Write for them, and make sure the text extracts cleanly.
What is generally true about how an ATS handles a cover letter
An applicant tracking system is, first, a database of applications. When you attach a cover letter, the file is stored next to your resume on your candidate record. Recruiters at Workday, Greenhouse, Lever and other employers can open it from there.
If the letter is a text-based PDF or a Word file, the text can be extracted. That makes it readable on screen and, in many systems, searchable. If the letter is a picture of text (a scan, or an export that flattened the page to an image), there is nothing to extract. The recruiter may still be able to open the image, but no software can read the words in it unless it runs OCR.
Where systems differ, and where employers configure them differently, is in the details: whether the letter is an upload or a pasted text box, whether it is required, where it appears on the recruiter's screen, and whether any of its text is used for matching. Those details are not documented publicly in a way we can verify, so this article doesn't give per-vendor rules.
What we don't know, and why that matters for your strategy
You will find confident claims online that one ATS "scores" cover letters and another ignores them, or that a letter can lower your match score. We have not seen published vendor documentation that confirms these, and we have not tested them ourselves. Some of these claims were in an earlier version of this article, and we have withdrawn them.
The practical effect is reassuring. You don't need a different cover letter strategy per ATS. You need a letter that:
- extracts as clean text, so it is readable and searchable wherever it lands, and
- makes a specific case a recruiter can act on in under a minute.
Why the format still matters
The same things that scramble a resume can scramble a cover letter, because the software reads the text in the order it sits in the file, not the order your eye follows on the page:
- Image-only files. A scanned letter, or one exported as an image, has no text layer. This is the same failure mode we describe for resumes in PDF vs Word for ATS.
- Sidebars and two-column letterheads. Some cover letter templates match a designed resume with a sidebar. A parser can read the sidebar first or interleave it with your paragraphs. We saw the sidebar read first when we ran a designed resume through our own parser in the Canva-style resume test.
- Text in headers, footers and text boxes. Contact details placed only in a page header can be duplicated or skipped by text extraction. Keep them in the body.
- Icons instead of words. A phone or envelope icon can turn into a stray character. Write "Phone" and "Email", or just the number and address.
If you can select the text in your PDF, copy it, and paste it into a plain text editor in the right order, the letter is in good shape.
When to include a cover letter (the practical rules)
- If the form asks for one, include one. A blank required field is a worse signal than a short letter.
- If it's optional, include one when you have something specific to say: why this company, why this role, a referral, a career change or a relocation the resume can't explain.
- Open with the point, not the formality. "I'm writing to apply for the X role at Y" wastes the line a recruiter reads first. Lead with what you would bring.
- Use the posting's own terms where they are true for you. If the posting says "stakeholder management" and you have done it, say it in those words, with an example. This helps the human reader and any search the recruiter runs.
- Complement the resume, don't repeat it. Pick one or two achievements and tell the story behind them. Don't paste your skills list.
- Keep it to 250 to 400 words. That respects the recruiter's time.
- Submit a text-based file. Export from Word or Google Docs, then check that the text can be selected and copied.
How to figure out which ATS the employer runs
It is useful to know, mainly so you can read the right platform guide. The application URL usually tells you:
- URL contains
myworkdayjobs.com→ Workday - URL contains
boards.greenhouse.ioorgreenhouse.io/jobs→ Greenhouse - URL contains
jobs.lever.co→ Lever - URL contains
icims.com→ iCIMS - URL contains
taleo.net→ Taleo - URL contains
successfactors.comorsapsf.com→ SAP SuccessFactors
If the URL is the employer's own domain (for example careers.acme.com), the apply button often redirects to one of the addresses above, or the page source mentions it.
How to check your cover letter before you send it
Two quick checks cover most problems:
- The copy-paste test. Open the PDF, select all, copy, and paste into a plain text editor. If the words come out in the right order with no stray symbols, the file is readable by text extraction.
- The content check. Paste your letter into our free cover letter checker. It checks length, weak phrases and numbers, and if you paste the job description too, shows which of the posting's terms your letter uses. It is a writing check on your text, not a simulation of any employer's ATS.
For the resume side, our free scanner runs your resume file through our own parser and shows what comes out: name, sections, dates and the structural issues it finds. The checks and scoring are explained on the methodology page.
→ Check your cover letter, free
If you want a head start on the letter itself, we made four free ATS-safe cover letter templates in Word format, with the guidance written into each paragraph: download the cover letter templates. Direct download, no email gate. And for the writing itself, the four paragraph formula is in how to write a cover letter.
